CMD Group is a ConstructConnect™ company. Learn more

The Implications of the Price Differential for Western Canadian Select

01/22/2013 by


Much of the Canadian economy is dependent on commodity prices. They have a big impact on the foreign trade balance. And they are a key determinant of the mega project investments initiated by resource sector owners.

Due first to the recession, then to the subsequent slower-than-usual improvement in the world economy, most commodity prices have been flat for the past couple of years.

That gives rise to an important question for the construction industry. What’s the outlook for resource projects?

There are two major factors that are having an impact. The first is specific to the energy sector. The second is of a more general nature, having to do with firms from emerging nations trying to lock up their raw material supplies by buying stakes in resource-sector firms in Canada, Australia and elsewhere, such as Africa. (I’ll have more to say on this in future Economy at a Glances, but for today, let’s concentrate on the oil price effect.)

The oil price effect begins with three different benchmarks for crude oil.

The current price of Brent crude, which governs half of the oil traded world-wide, is about $20 U.S. per barrel higher than West Texas (WTI) Intermediate. WTI is the U.S. standard.

The Brent price originally derived from an offshore field in the North Sea. It governs oil sales in Europe and Japan and in most emerging nations, including China and India.

For Canada, a third benchmark has become critically important – the price for “Western Canadian Select” (WCS). The composition of WCS is different than for Brent and WTI. It’s mainly “heavy” oil, with some admixtures to make it flow more easily, whereas the other two are “lighter”.

Lighter crudes can be processed (i.e., refined) into gasoline more easily.

WCS needs an intermediate stage of refining – i.e., from “heavy” to “light” – to render it suitable for final stage processing. The intermediate stage is usually done in heavy oil upgraders. (Due to their high cost of construction, Western Canada has only a handful of upgraders).

There should be a price differential between the lighter crude varieties and WCS, but at this time, that separation has become much greater than normal. It’s having a major impact on the outlook for the Canadian oil industry.

The price of WCS is $40 U.S. per barrel lower than for WTI and $60 per barrel less than for Brent.

WTI is currently falling below the Brent price because the U.S. has a glut of supply. Hydraulic fracturing isn’t just opening up new supplies of natural gas. It’s also freeing up a great deal more oil.

The only way for U.S. producers to realize the Brent price is to ship oil to refineries on the coasts (Atlantic, Pacific or the Gulf of Mexico) that can sell to customers offshore, mainly in emerging nations. 

Canadian producers are operating under an additional set of handicaps. They basically have customers in only one country other than at home, the U.S. And they have only limited access to coastal refineries.

Most WCS is piped to refineries or transportation hubs that are inland in the U.S. For example, TransCanada Corp.’s current U.S. pipeline ends at Cushing, Oklahoma. Due to the surfeit of product from American sources, the price offered at Cushing for Alberta crude carries a large discount.

This is negative for our national interests in several ways. Canadian producers are being paid far less than they should be. The U.S. energy sector is being subsidized by Canadian producers. And the government of Alberta’s financial coffers, due to lower than expected royalty payments, are suffering.

Also, weaker tax revenue for Alberta hurts the rest of the country through reduced transfer payments.

What’s the answer? We’re seeing corporate responses in the headlines every day.

Later this year, TransCanada will complete the southern portion of its XL pipeline – from Cushing to the Gulf Coast – and that will help.

There’s also a major push underway to proceed with the northern portion of the XL line. This needs approval from Washington because it crosses the border with Canada.

In the run-up to the Presidential election, Mr. Obama placed the northern portion of XL on hold to appease the environmental lobby within the Democratic Party. The potential threat to a sensitive aquifer in Nebraska was the excuse. 

The company has since filed a revised route circling most of the sensitive region to the east. Legislators in Nebraska are now expected to endorse the project.

Better access to American markets is only part of the answer. We need more foreign customers, and for the most part, that means in Asia.

Hence the impetus behind Enbridge’s new Northern Gateway Pipeline to Prince Rupert, B.C., and Kinder Morgan’s TransMountain pipeline expansion to Burnaby. Both are in the midst of hearings.

There are also proposals to make better use of some existing pipelines. This might involve switching some underutilized lines from natural gas to oil. Or there might be some flow reversals. For example, rather than taking foreign oil from the Atlantic Coast and shipping it to refineries in Ontario and Quebec, it might make more sense to send Alberta crude all the way across country to find customers along the U.S. seaboard or in Europe.

There’s also another response that’s shaping investment dramatically in North America. The railroads have spotted the potential for their alternative delivery systems.

What are the positives for oil tanker-car delivery by rail?

The railroads already reach almost everywhere. This includes refinery capacity on the coasts, as well as in large urban centres where new pipelines would have little chance of finding public acceptance, never mind that their cost of building would be prohibitive.

The railroads can increase volumes in easy incremental stages, in most cases without environmental hearings. Oil spills from tanker cars are more common than from pipelines, but the damage is smaller and can be contained more easily.

Both the railroads and the oil companies are rapidly increasing their investments in storage tanks along railroad lines. Orders for tanker cars have increased to the point where delivery dates are now running two years into the future. 

The oil market in North American is in considerable flux. While the industry is showing itself sensitive to environmental and native land claim issues, it’s also been quicker on its feet than many might have expected.

The industry’s executives are demonstrating commendable flexibility in seeking imaginative solutions.

Alex Carrick

Find Canadian construction-related economic articles in Canadian Construction Market News and in the Economic Outlook section of Daily Commercial News.

Recent Comments

Article Archive

Date Article
11/17/14 Top 10 largest construction project starts in the U.S. - October 2014
11/14/14 Non-residential Construction Starts Rose Gently in October
07/10/14 The Importance of Matching Volume to Contractor Capacity in JOC Procurement Strategy
07/10/14 Consider a Seed Project as Part of Your JOC Procurement Strategy
07/10/14 The Best Unit Price Book for Your Job Order Contract
07/02/14 ECONOMIC NUGGETS – July 1, 2014
10/23/14 Twenty major upcoming Water Treatment Plants and Manufacturing & Warehousing construction projects - U.S. - October 2014
10/23/14 Twenty major upcoming Alberta and British Columbia construction projects - Canada - October 2014
10/15/14 Trend lines of construction starts in Canada - September 2014
10/15/14 Top 10 largest construction project starts in Canada - September 2014
09/17/14 Twenty major upcoming midwest and northwest construction projects - U.S. - September 2014
09/17/14 Twenty major upcoming medical and educational construction projects - Canada - September 2014
09/17/14 Trend lines of construction starts in Canada - August 2014
09/17/14 Top 10 largest construction project starts in Canada - August 2014
08/15/14 Twenty major upcoming medical and educational construction projects - U.S. - August 2014
08/15/14 Twenty major upcoming industrial and water treatment construction projects - Canada - July 2014
08/15/14 Trend lines of construction starts in Canada - July 2014
08/15/14 Top 10 largest construction project starts in Canada - July 2014
07/24/14 Twenty major upcoming entertainment facility and stadium/arena construction projects - U.S. - July 2014
07/24/14 Twenty major upcoming Ontario and Quebec construction projects - Canada - July 2014
07/24/14 Trend lines of construction starts in Canada - June 2014
07/24/14 Top 10 largest construction project starts in Canada - June 2014
07/14/14 Top 10 largest construction project starts in the U.S. - June 2014
02/03/14 Infographic: Where Can You Use Project Leads in the Construction Process?
07/25/13 The Canadian Economy’s Two Great Blessings
02/15/13 Construction Economic Notes – February, 2013
11/05/12 Recycled-Content Tile
10/05/12 Fiber-Cement Siding
09/18/12 Return on Your Green Home Improvement Investment
08/09/12 Green Building Solutions to Stormwater Runoff
08/07/12 An “Aha” Moment Solves Challenge of Cost Estimating Local Circus Roof
07/19/12 Estimate Types
06/20/12 Ground-Source Heat Pump
05/14/12 Universal Design for Outdoor Living
04/23/12 What Is Universal Design?
04/09/12 Natural Landscaping
03/14/12 Green Material Alternatives for Plumbing Fixtures
03/02/12 Budgeting & Financing Green Construction
02/22/12 Greening Your Firm
02/10/12 Roofing Defects
02/06/12 Roofs: energy efficiency strategies
01/18/12 Commercial Real Estate and Green Construction
12/14/11 Renewable Energy & Distributed Generation Technologies
11/04/11 Tubular Skylights
10/04/11 Are Online Ads An Endangered Species?
09/27/11 Performance Bonds Guarantee Clients Receive Exceptional Service
09/15/11 Deconstruction for Green and Economic Benefit
09/01/11 4 Ways for Businesses to Create a Good First Impression on Twitter
08/11/11 Building Information Modeling (BIM) for Green Building
07/21/11 Green Alternatives for Concrete
07/12/11 Evaluating Products Over Their Life Cycle
06/30/11 Low-Cost Green Strategies
06/28/11 Bricks are from Venus, Clicks are from Mars
06/17/11 Zombie Avoidance Techniques for Building Product Manufacturers
06/08/11 Blogs & Websites: The 5 Signs of Website Wellness
06/06/11 Building Product Manufacturers & Green Products
06/01/11 Is Fear of Sharing Information Costing Your Company Sales?
05/26/11 What Are Green Products?
05/20/11 The Building Envelope
05/16/11 Blogging: Website Heal Thyself
05/03/11 Metals Compared to Wood for Sustainable Construction
04/12/11 Storm Water Collection & Infiltration
03/23/11 Commissioning the Green Building
02/23/11 Building Program for Green Design
01/21/11 Building Deconstruction Process
05/02/11 Why Building Product Manufacturers and Social Media Are a Marriage Made in Heaven
05/06/11 Building Product Manufacturers: How Understanding Architects Can Help Your Business
10/21/09 Distributors & Manufacturer Representatives
07/15/10 Estimating Doors: Tips from the Experts
07/06/10 How to Handle Construction Materials to Prevent Mold
06/21/10 How to Maximize the Benefits of Exterior Security Lighting
06/04/10 SmartBuilding Index
06/01/10 Regional Housing Construction Tracking and Forecast Information
05/28/10 How to Find Regional Construction Tracking and Forecast Information
05/24/10 Building Product Manufacturers
05/18/10 Practicing the Art of Sustainability - Why Atlanta's Current Building Codes Need Updating Now
02/23/10 Learning to use EE
01/11/10 Earn AIA CEU Credit Attending RCD Webcasts
07/17/09 Cost Estimators Winning Work With BIM
07/16/09 Becoming an Invited Bidder - More Tips
07/16/09 Becoming an Invited Bidder - Tips
07/16/09 Becoming an Invited Bidder
07/16/09 SmartBIM Object Modeling Guidelines for Revit
07/15/09 Interference Check and BIM
06/26/09 A Look at Contractor Failure: Part 2
06/19/09 RicciGreene Associates
06/19/09 Doug Thornton AIA, LEED A.P. of AERC, PLLC
06/18/09 A Look at Contractor Failure: Part 1
06/12/09 Owners and SmartBIM Objects – What You Need To Do
06/10/09 Dealing with the IRS
06/05/09 Getting Paid on Construction Contracts
06/02/09 BIM Coordination and Collaboration
05/28/09 Marketing Your Construction Firm on the Cheap
05/20/09 Little Habits with Big Payoffs for Contractors
05/12/09 SmartBIM Spaces
05/07/09 AIA Show Recap as Seen by the SmartBIM Solutions Team
04/27/09 Business Case Study - Survey Of Spending Patterns In Educational Facilities
04/23/09 Taking Advantage of the Recession: Hiring the Right People
04/20/09 Cork as a Green Flooring Option
04/08/09 Owners - It's Time to Substantially Increase Your Architect's and Engineer's Fees
03/05/09 There's a Solution to Performing Time Consuming Quantity Take-Offs
02/20/09 SmartBIM Library is Half-Off for a Limited Time Only
02/09/09 You are Wasting Your Money
01/20/09 Obama: 'Dramatic Action' On Economy Needed
01/14/09 Use of BIM Jumps Dramatically Over Last 12 Months
12/10/08 Minimizing the Size of Family Files (Revit Objects)
11/11/08 Maximize Online Advertising Dollars
11/07/08 Architects and Engineers, WE NEED YOU
10/29/08 Why Do You Need SmartBIM Objects
10/28/08 Why Building Information Modeling?
10/29/08 10 Questions To Ask About BIM Objects
10/08/08 The Object Mess
10/07/08 Implementing BIM to Your Office
10/06/08 Meeting the Needs for Governmental BIM Compliance while Avoiding Current Liability Obstacles
09/15/08 The BIM Transformation is Manageable with the NEW SmartBIM Library v3
09/14/08 KOLBE Windows and Doors vs. Building Information Modeling
09/12/08 The Evolution of Building Information Modeling: BIM 1-2-3
08/11/08 BIM 101 Overview - From Hand Drawings, CAD and now BIM
08/12/08 Draper, Inc. on BIM Object Developments
07/08/08 IFD Library Partners work to establish standards for creators of BIM software
06/23/08 Architectural Education
06/17/08 Parametric Revit Objects – Part I - Fundamentals
06/17/08 Window Glazing Coefficients
06/01/08 Frequently Asked Questions About Building Codes
06/05/08 Calling All Current and Prospective Revit Users - This Blog Is For You
05/06/08 System Requirements for SmartBIM Library
05/06/08 SmartBIM Library 2.0 Release Notes
05/05/08 Building Information Modeling Moves into AEC Mainstream, Adding Value to Project Delivery Process
04/08/08 Flooring: Cost Considerations
02/08/10 General Contractors & Trade Contractors
01/24/08 Building Element Models (BEM)
12/21/07 LEED Certification Primer
12/13/07 Building Integrated Photovoltaics (BIPV)
09/24/07 Mixed-mode Building Design Combines Old and New Ideas
10/15/07 Checklists Identify Potential Envelope Design Improvements
10/24/07 Greenroofs as High Performance Design
10/21/07 What Makes a Building Product Green
10/24/07 Lighting Considerations in Green Building
10/24/07 Water Conservation in Green Buildings
10/24/07 Rainwater Collection Systems
10/24/07 Efficient Cooling Methods for Green Buildings
10/24/07 Controlling Heat Transfer in Green Buildings
10/24/07 Limiting Heat Loss Through Windows
10/23/07 Formaldehyde Use in Building Construction
10/23/07 Using Plants to Improve Indoor Air Quality
11/05/07 Greening Healthcare
10/19/07 Daylighting Controls
10/19/07 Use of Windows, Skylights and Light Pipes in Daylighting
10/19/07 An Overview of Daylighting
10/19/07 An Overview of Solar Ventilation Air Heating
10/19/07 Types of Collectors for Solar Water Heating
10/19/07 An Overview of Solar Water Heating
10/19/07 Cooling Load Advoidance
10/19/07 Components of Passive Solar Heating Designs
10/19/07 An Overview of Passive Solar Heating
10/23/07 Improving Indoor Air Quality
10/19/07 An Overview of The LEED Rating System
10/19/07 Cost Considerations in Building Deconstruction
10/17/07 Building Deconstruction
10/25/07 Roofing Considerations in Green Building
10/19/07 Green Site Selection and Development
10/24/07 Reducing Energy Use in Buildings
10/17/07 Green Demolition
10/18/07 Integrating Solar Power Generation into Buildings using Thin Film PV
09/10/07 Compost Company Promotes Green Environment
03/31/06 Green Roof Sets An Example For Minneapolis Sustainable Design

CMD Group- construction industry news-image” title=